ELCA: Commute the Sentence of Death for Leroy McGill
On Wednesday, May 20, Arizona inmate Leroy McGill is set to be put to death by lethal injection at the state prison in Florence, AZ. On October 27, 2004, a jury found Leroy McGill guilty of the first degree premeditated murder of Charles Perez, the attempted first degree murder of Nova Banta, two counts of arson, and the endangerment of Jack Yates, Jeffrey Uhl, and Mary Near.
The following letter asking Governor Katie Hobbs to commute the sentence of death for Leroy McGill was sent to Gov. Hobbs from the ELCA Witness in Society office in Washington, D.C. on May 4, 2026. Signatories were the Rev. Amy E. Reumann, Senior Director of Witness in Society, ELCA; the Rev. Deborah K. Hutterer, Bishop of the Grand Canyon Synod, ELCA; and Solveig Muus, Director of Lutheran Advocacy Ministry Arizona.
May 4th, 2026
Governor Katie Hobbs
1700 W. Washington St.
Phoenix, Arizona 85007
Dear Governor Hobbs,
On behalf of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, we write to urge you to commute the sentence of death for Leroy McGill, who is scheduled to be executed on May 20th, 2026.
The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA), a national denomination of 2,700,000 members, including 25,200 in your state, opposes capital punishment. We believe and teach that all life is sacred, and the death penalty undermines this belief by perpetuating cycles of violence and injustice. God’s intention for a just society, expressed in the teachings of Jesus, emphasizes nonviolence, mercy, and compassion over punishment.
The ELCA social statement on the death penalty1 sets forth this church’s objection to capital punishment, which is rooted in the Scriptural call to Christians to respond to violence through restorative justice for victims and perpetrators, rather than by exacting revenge. The social statement sets forth:
“It is because of this church’s ministry with and to people affected by violent crime that we oppose the death penalty.” This church’s stance is informed by the ministry of our congregations with offenders, victims, and their families. The ELCA teaches that following Christ is to commit to restorative justice (Matthew 5:38-39, John 8:3-11) and to address each person impacted by violent crime. Capital punishment denies victims and their families, and offenders, the chance for redemption and restorative justice. Instead, the death penalty seeks retribution, sometimes vengeance, and fails to address the systemic issues of our broken society.
“It is because of this church’s commitment to justice that we oppose the death penalty.” The death penalty has never been, nor can it be, administered restoratively or justly. Race, gender, mental health conditions, age, affluence, geography, and more all affect the judgment regarding the sentence of capital punishment. The ELCA continues to advocate for a more holistic and restorative alternative to capital punishment.
“It is because of this church’s concern regarding the actual use of the death penalty that we oppose its imposition.” Human beings are imperfect; innocent lives have been taken by the sentence of the death penalty in the past and inevitably again in the future. This is a mistake we cannot correct. The death penalty has not been proven to deter violence or make society safer. By continuing its practice, we send a message of brutality and violence.
The ELCA affirms the state’s responsibility under God for the protection of citizens and maintenance of justice and public order. This does not mean that governments have an unlimited right to take life or that crimes must be punished by death.
As a church, we arrive at our positions through gathering in faith, engaging in moral deliberation, recognizing the dignity of every human, and striving for justice. In that spirit, we urge you to commute the death sentence for Leroy McGill and to work towards abolishing the death penalty in Arizona.
Sincerely,
The Rev. Amy E. Reumann
Senior Director of Witness in Society, ELCA
The Rev. Deborah K. Hutterer
Bishop of the Grand Canyon Synod, ELCA
Solveig Muus
Director of Lutheran Advocacy Ministry Arizona